From start to finish, every bite/sip at
Per Se was delicious! I'll say off the bat that I give it 5 out of 5 dishes. Wonderful lunch. I definitely have to mention that we ate (my mom and I) in the Salon part of the restaurant and not the main dining room. It's the same food, but you can order a la carte, instead of the $275 prix-fixe meal. Lunch in the Salon area is served Friday/Saturday/Sunday from 11:30 am - 2:00 pm. We arrived at 11:30 am and were the only ones there; only 1 other table filled up while we were there. And by table, I mean couches with coffee table like tables in front of you. We got the best table in the house - by the window overlooking Columbus Circle and Central Park. (see photo). The staff was great -- friendly, but not too friendly, and very helpful with anything you need. The menu changes daily -- our selections ranged from $28 - $46, with a variety of options: salad of spring onions (mom's choice), beef (my choice, see above photo), foie gras, pasta, sturgeon, lobster, and pork belly. You are told that you can order as many (or as few) courses as you want. After we ordered, we were brought 3 different amuse bouche items -- all equally delicious. First, we each had 1 tiny cheese puff that had tons of flavor; then, we each had a cone of salmon tartare, followed by a good portion of warm celery soup, served with a beautiful presentation -- see photo -- where you can also see my $19 glass of Riesling which was delicious, and their pretty water glasses that look like plastic, but are thin glass.
We also had a beautiful bread basket with butter from Vermont. Then our main course arrived. My beef was perfectly cooked as the chef recommends it - medium rare (my favorite anyway), with white/green/yellow asparagus and a 'pain perdu a la moelle' on the side - which I learned is french for: bone marrow french toast. Every bite had amazing flavor!! My mom's salad was equally good, but very light -- and a very pretty dish as well. After my beef, I decided we should try the Cheese Plate as well, which was sooooo good. A selection of 4 cheeses (pata cabra, tilsiter, berkswell and asher blue -- I saved the daily printed menu -- I did not remember all of the cheeses from memory). It was served with 4 little dishes with: orange blossom honey, onion marmalade, candied pecans, eggplant caponata -- and 2 selections of new types of bread. LOVED it. And, we still had room for dessert, of course. Was there any question?? We shared a 'Brownie and Malted Milk' dish that was a chocolate brownie with pecan 'marquise,' with caramel ice cream. It was a very pretty dish, but I didn't love it. At least they also brought us a tray of other mini chocolates/candies to try, plus sent us away with a package of shortbread cookies with chocolate inside -- with 4 cookies in it -- for each of us. It was a fabulous long lunch, overlooking the park, and I can't wait to go back another time. While I left full, I wasn't too full at all. I was ready for a great afternoon at the theatre seeing Memphis! (highly recommend it; great new Broadway musical).....5 out of 5 dishes, definitely!!
And now on to
Daniel, which was another great dining experience in New York with my mom (not on the same day though). While I really really enjoyed it all, I must say I wasn't overwhelmed by it, and I do rate my lunch at Per Se higher than dinner at Daniel. Maybe I'm not comparing apples to apples, but I am comparing the flavor in the food, the staff/service, and the little touches that each of them made. We ate in the Lounge area of Daniel, but it's not really very different from the main dining room, except for 2 things: you can dress casually (there was a man in jeans), and you have the option to order 1 or 2 courses, instead of the 3 course prix-fixe in the main dining room. While I still ordered 3 courses, my mom had 2 -- however, they brought her some soup during my appetizer -- so she 'didn't feel left out,' they said. The Lounge area is a good size and our table was a 2-top where I sat on the bench with my mom across from me. Comfy pillows were there for me to use, and they offered my mom a mini ottoman for her purse - nice touch. After ordering, we were brought a 3-tiered tray with amuse bouche to try. One was lobster, but I can't remember the others -- must not have made an impression. My first course was crab wrapped in delicious golden delicious apples -- see photo above. While it was a pretty dish and tasted very good, it didn't have as much crab flavor as I would have liked. The bread they served tableside was also good, but not amazing. On to the main course -- my poached chicken was really good -- flavorful and moist -- and a big dish - more than I was expecting. My mom loved her dover sole as well - well flavored and interested ingredients, it came with fava beans, onions, arugula and pink peppercorn sauce. On to dessert, my favorite part of the Daniel meal. I ordered the chocolate peanut butter tart and it was fabulous - I can still taste it. Photo below..I wish I could have it again right now. My mom ordered coffee ice cream, which was good, but nothing too original, except for the pretty serving dish; plus they brought us another dessert from the menu to try -- rhubarb tart, which was just ok. I guess if you love rhubarb, you might have liked it more than me. Then they brought us AWESOME mini madeleines to try -- I probably ate 4 or 5 of them. Then they brought us a tray of petit fours with more wonderful bites of deliciousness. Then they brought a 4-part tray tableside and we got to choose 1 more piece of chocolate to try. I was in chocolate heaven and was really full by the time we left. A great experience with very good food and excellent desserts. # of dishes: 4.5 out of 5 dishes.